Cybersecurity

How to run a phishing test for your employees

By Syxel Technologies · · 8 min read
Letter tiles spelling the word phishing

A phishing test, also called a phishing simulation, sends your staff realistic but harmless scam emails to see who clicks, who types in a password and who reports the message. Run well, it is a training exercise that shows where people need help and whether your training is working. Run badly, it embarrasses staff and teaches them to distrust IT. This guide walks through how to run a phishing test for your employees fairly and usefully.

Phishing quiz or phishing simulation?

They do different jobs. A phishing quiz is a test people know they are taking. It is a good way to teach the warning signs and start a conversation, and it can be shared with the whole team in a minute. A phishing simulation arrives unannounced in real inboxes, so it measures what people actually do on a busy day. Most organizations get the best results from both: a quiz to teach, then simulations to check that the lessons stick.

Step 1: Get management sign-off and set the rules

Get written approval from senior management before anything is sent, and involve HR. Agree in advance:

  • who knows the dates, kept to a small group so results are realistic;
  • what the results will be used for: training, not discipline;
  • which topics are off limits, such as fake pay rises, bonuses or health scares, which damage trust when they turn out to be a test;
  • that the landing page will never store what people type, so no real passwords are collected;
  • who staff can contact if they are worried they fell for a real scam.

Step 2: Tell staff it is training, not a trap

Announce the programme in general terms, without dates: the organization will send practice phishing emails from time to time, the aim is to learn, and reporting a suspicious email is always the right move. Mention it in your security or acceptable use policy. People who know testing happens tend to report more, which is exactly the habit you want.

Step 3: Allowlist the simulation

Your email filter is designed to block exactly this kind of message, so your IT staff or IT provider will need to allowlist the simulation's sending servers so the test reaches inboxes. Some security tools also open links automatically to check them, which can look like clicks in your results; your provider can filter those out. While IT is looking at email, check your own domain with our free email security checker: SPF, DKIM and DMARC stop real criminals sending email that appears to come from you.

Step 4: Choose realistic scenarios

The best scenarios look like messages your staff really receive. For businesses in Jamaica and the Caribbean that often means a fake bank alert, a courier or customs fee, a utility bill, a shared document you were not expecting, or a supplier invoice with new bank details. Match scenarios to roles, so finance staff see invoice and payment requests and front-desk staff see booking or delivery messages. Start with easier emails, then make them harder as people improve.

Step 5: Measure the right things

  • Clicked: who opened the link. Useful, but a click alone is not the whole story.
  • Entered details: who typed a username or password on the fake page. This is the most serious outcome.
  • Reported: who flagged the email to IT or used the report button. This is the most important positive measure.
  • Time to first report: how quickly someone raised the alarm, which shows how fast your organization could respond to a real attack.

Open rates are unreliable, because many email apps load images automatically or block them. Rather than comparing yourself with published averages, compare each campaign with your own first one. Fewer people entering details and more people reporting is real progress.

Step 6: Teach in the moment, then follow up

Anyone who clicks should land on a short page that explains, kindly, what gave the email away. Then use the results to shape your next training session, focusing on the scenarios and departments that struggled. Share overall results with staff, not names. Our security awareness training works this way: quarterly sessions with simulations in between, each session targeting the gaps the last campaign showed.

Step 7: Repeat on a schedule

A single test gives you a snapshot. Running simulations every quarter, with different scenarios each time, shows whether behaviour is improving and keeps the warning signs fresh. Vary the timing so people do not learn to expect a test on the first Monday of the month.

Make reporting easy and thank people for it

Give staff one simple way to report a suspicious email, such as a report button or a single email address, and thank everyone who uses it, even for false alarms. Remember that scams also arrive by text message and WhatsApp; cover these in training with real examples, and keep our guide on what to do when a WhatsApp account is hacked handy. If someone does fall for a real phish and an account holding personal data is affected, Jamaica's Data Protection Act may require a report to the Information Commissioner within 72 hours, so fast reporting matters.

Phishing tests for teams across the Caribbean

We run phishing simulations and quarterly training for organizations in Jamaica and remotely for teams in other Caribbean markets. In the Cayman Islands, CIMA's cybersecurity Rule expects regulated entities to run a training and awareness programme, and simulation results give boards a record to review. In the British Virgin Islands, we model scenarios on the intermediary and payment requests that registered agents and trust companies handle every day.

Frequently asked questions

Is it fair to send phishing tests to employees?

Phishing simulations are a common part of security training. Keep them fair: get written approval from management, involve HR, tell staff that a testing programme exists, avoid upsetting topics such as fake pay or health news, never collect real passwords, and use the results for training rather than punishment.

How often should we run a phishing test?

Quarterly works well for most organizations, alongside short training sessions. Change the scenarios each time and vary the timing so staff cannot predict them.

What should happen to employees who click?

They should see a short explanation of the warning signs straight away, and the next training session should cover the scenario. Repeated clicks are a reason for extra coaching, not public blame. People who are afraid of punishment stop reporting, which is the opposite of what you want.

What is a good phishing test result?

The best measure is your own trend: fewer people entering details and more people reporting suspicious emails, faster, from one campaign to the next. Your first campaign gives you the baseline to compare against.

Is the Spot the phish quiz free?

Yes. Our Spot the phish quiz is free and needs no sign-up. It shows ten realistic emails, asks whether each is phishing or legitimate, and explains the clues after every answer. You can share the link with your whole team.

Get a quote